As we reported last week, Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) recently issued 1,000 Notices of Inspection to employers across the US. It appears that in many instances, these Notices are accompanied by a subpoena. Whereas the Notice requires employers to present only their I-9 forms, the subpoenas are much more comprehensive and require employers to produce the following:
- Original I-9 forms and copies of supporting documents
- Employee roster or payroll
- Monthly payroll reports
- Copies of State Wage Detail Reports and Unemployment Insurance Quarterly Tax Reports
- Copies of Quarterly Tax Statements
- Independent Contactor Rosters including dates of hire and termination
- Copies of Tax Form 1099 for all independent contractors
- Lists of all individuals employed on a sporadic, irregular or intermittent basis and not deemed to be an employee
- Copies of Social Security Administration Employer Correction Requests
- Copies of petitions filed with the Immigration Service on behalf of employees
- Copies of the business’s articles of incorporation, business license and annual reports
- Employer Identification Number (EIC) and Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) documentation
- Copies of all company procedures and/or policies regarding Form I-9 preparation
Employers are also being asked to provide information about use of temporary staffing agencies, participation in E-Verify, and any previous I-9 inspections by the Department of Labor. Employers typically have less than a week to gather, prepare and present all of these items.
If your company receives a Notice of Inspection with or without a subpoena you must act immediately. Contact us, we can help.
If you’d like help getting your files, Form I-9s and policies in place before there is a knock at the door, we can help with that too.


As reported in local news, the crackdown on employers continues. In Minnesota 1,200 employees of ABM were fired in October. ABM is a large U.S. company who contracts to provide janitorial services to large office buildings; the fired employees all worked as janitors for the company. The firings came about as the result of a government audit of the company’s I-9 forms. It appears the company has cooperated fully with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, though ABM’s cooperation does not mean they will avoid civil or criminal charges. This quieter type of immigration raid is in keeping with the stated intention of this Administration to focus its efforts on employer compliance.
On October 28th, President Obama signed the
Completing I-9s correctly when there are out-of-state employees or employer locations in different states is a challenge for many companies. Unfortunately, there is no easy answer to this problem. The solution that will work best for your company depends upon the company set up and practices. To restate the I-9 basics, the employer must review original documents and complete the I-9 correctly and in a timely manner – there is no way around these requirements even for out-of-state offices or employees. If new out-of-state hires are not brought to a main office to complete paperwork, you must have an out-of-state employer representative or agent reviewing original documents. The completion timeline still holds as well; employees must complete Section 1 of the I-9 by the close of business on their first day, and employers have until the third business day to review original documents and complete Section 2. Is your company compliant? If you have concerns, or questions about instituting policies and procedures that will work for your company, please
It appears that the
In case you haven’t seen it yet, the USCIS released supplemental E-Verify guidance specifically for Federal Contractors. This 22-page document can be found
Recent reports indicate businesses have been receiving a new type of letter from the Social Security Administration. These letters state that the business has been selected randomly to take part in a Social Security Administration study and request information about specific employees. The letters include questions about the employees’ original employment applications, Social Security Numbers and documents. If your company receives one of these letters, please proceed carefully and consult with legal counsel before responding. In addition to labor law and immigration law considerations, privacy issues and potential fraud should also be considered.
Last Friday, a Missouri poultry processing company paid $450,000 in administrative fines following a 2007 worksite enforcement investigation. The fine will be used by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to fund future enforcement activities. In addition to the fine, the settlement requires the company to train all Human Resources personnel, and set up company compliance policies to ensure that all Immigration laws are followed. In the